We have frequently reported on plaintiffs’ efforts to salvage untimely claims in the Taxotere MDL. See, for example, here, here, and here. As we explained here, the basic problem for many plaintiffs—who claim that the chemotherapy drug Taxotere caused them permanent hair loss—is how the MDL master complaint defines the plaintiffs’
Search results for: taxotere
Taxotere MDL Denies Plaintiffs’ Attempt to Undo Lone Pine Order
Happy Taxotere Week to all who celebrate. We doubt that many of our plaintiff attorney friends will be putting out the bunting and frosting the cakes, as the Taxotere decisions we are discussing this week are mostly bad for the left side of the v.
Today’s opinion, In re Taxotere (Docetaxel) Products Liability…
No Second Chance at Service for Taxotere Plaintiffs
We posted last year about plaintiffs who were dismissed from the Taxotere MDL for failure to serve defendants. To put it simply, the Federal Rules still apply in an MDL. 153 plaintiffs didn’t comply with the Rules, and their cases were dismissed. Not knowing when to walk away, as Kenny Rogers instructs, a number of these plaintiffs filed for reconsideration. The MDL Court rightly shut them down.Continue Reading No Second Chance at Service for Taxotere Plaintiffs
More Taxotere Remand Courts Deny Untimely Amendments
The orders denying untimely, post-remand attempts to amend complaints in the Taxotere litigation are piling up, and it doesn’t get old. We recently reported on one such denial in the Northern District of California. In recent weeks, district courts in New York, North Carolina, and Tennessee (among others) have joined in. Today we report on three of those decisions.Continue Reading More Taxotere Remand Courts Deny Untimely Amendments
Taxotere Remand Court Torpedoes Tardy Amendment
McMillian v. Sanofi-Aventis U.S. LLC, 2024 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 44783 (March 13, 2024), is another example where a court shot down a belated, post-remand attempt by a Taxotere plaintiff to change the allegations of her complaint. You might think that we will mimic some of our earlier posts about remand courts fixing a mess…
Enough Is Enough In Taxotere Remand Case
The unwieldy and sometimes unfair nature of multidistrict litigation has become a recurring theme on the DDL Blog. We have long commented on the “if you build it, they will come” dynamic that leads to hundreds or thousands of cases gathered, filed, and then parked in an MDL—all hoping to do as little…
Third Times a Charm for Lone Pine in Taxotere MDL
If at first you don’t succeed . . . re-urge. That’s the word the MDL court used in In re: Taxotere (Docetaxel) Products Liability Litigation, 2024 WL 718698 (E.D. La. Feb. 21, 2024). Defendants urged, re-urged, and again re-urged the court to enter a Lone Pine Order. And after four years of re-urging, the…
Taxotere MDL Dismisses Plaintiffs Who Failed to Perfect Service by Deadline
It is time, once again, to talk about Multidistrict Litigation (MDL) case management. But this time there will be more gratitude than grousing.
We wince when we hear judges talk about managing litigation. Such management seems to be about many things (mostly about forcing settlement), and not much about deciding legal issues, and definitely not…
Taxotere Timing Troubles Persistently Plague Plaintiffs
We’ve blogged before about the plaintiffs’ self-defeating “injury” definition in the Taxotere mass tort litigation. Specifically, plaintiffs have defined their injury as being hair loss that persists more than six months after their cessation of treatment with the defendant’s cancer chemotherapy drug. But, because this litigation (like most product liability MDLs) only exists because of lawyer solicitation, such solicitation dredges up many plaintiffs who sat on their hands for much longer than the aforesaid six month period. Having a date certain as to when the injury exists greatly assists any defendant in winning dismissal of these stale claims on statute of limitations grounds.
That’s not just true in the Taxotere MDLContinue Reading Taxotere Timing Troubles Persistently Plague Plaintiffs
Punting Generic Drug Preemption In The Taxotere MDL
We have posted quite a bit about the Taxotere MDL and some Fifth Circuit decisions on appeals from it. The decisions have mostly been pretty good. We have posted even more about the treatment of broad preemption issues in MDLs in recent years. From our perspective, there have been too many denials of strong defense…