[T]he common law of public nuisance is an inapt vehicle for addressing the conduct at issue. Mass harms caused by
Search results for: nuisance
Update on the New 4th Edition of the Reference Manual on Scientific Evidence
Last month we were one of the first on the web with a review of the new Reference Manual on Scientific Evidence, Fourth Edition. Since it was nearly 1700 pages long – literally longer than “War & Peace” – we did only the most cursory of analyses, describing differences in topics and authors…
Digital Health Liability Law In Flux
Not quite three years ago, we co-authored a chapter in a Digital Health guide put out by International Comparative Legal Guides. It bore the pithy title “Predicting Risk and Examining the Intersection of Traditional Principles of Product Liability Laws with Digital Health.” We continue to tinker with the principles of product liability law…
Running the Table – The Ten Best Prescription Drug/Medical Device Decisions of 2025
A year ago, Bexis thought this would be the last blogpost he would ever write, and that he would retire along with 2025. Not gonna happen – at least not yet, thanks to Reed Smith making him an offer he couldn’t refuse. Bexis will be stepping back from some things, but not from the Blog. …
Running on Empty -The Ten Worst Prescription Drug/Medical Device Decisions Of 2025
It’s time for our annual parade of horribles. It’s no fun, but somebody needs to do it, if only to make sure that the other side, and those who aid and abet them, know that we are paying attention. So here is our annual naughty list, the bottom ten worst prescription medical product liability litigation…
Fen-Phen Flashback
It feels like 20 years ago when we were doing almost monthly fen-phen diet drug trials in the Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas. The old timey-air-conditioning units in City Hall, along with subways rumbling underfoot, occasionally drowned out the testimony of plaintiff experts taking both scientific studies and internal company documents out of context. That…
Design Defect Claims Preempted In GLP-1 MDL
The day before this post went live there was a retirement ceremony for Judge Jon P. McCalla, the federal district judge for whom we clerked three decades ago. After serving as an Army officer in the Vietnam War, Judge McCalla got his J.D. from Vanderbilt and clerked for Judge Bailey Brown of the Western District…
Guest Post – The Product Line Is Moving – and Software Might Be Switching Sides
Today we have a guest post on some recent developments on whether strict liability applies to software, apps, artificial intelligence, and other forms of electronic data, which depends, as this 50-state survey addresses, on whether such intangible items meet the common-law definition of “product.” It is by Reed Smith attorneys (and repeat guest posters) Mildred…
Unanimous Supreme Court Slaps Down Familiar Sounding Marketing Allegations In Landmark Gun Decision
We weren’t expecting to find anything bloggable when we reviewed the Supreme Court’s recent unanimous decision in Smith & Wesson Brands, Inc. v. Estados Unidos Mexicanos, ___ U.S. ___, 2025 WL 1583281 (U.S. June 5, 2025). But we were struck by the familiarity of the allegations of illegal marketing that the Court in S&W held could not be passed off as “aiding and abetting.” These were the same tired and repetitive allegations of purported “illegal marketing” by independent actors in the distribution chain that we have seen in so many drug/device cases – sometimes masquerading as “public nuisance.”
We think our clients can use S&W against such allegations, at least by analogy.
Continue Reading Unanimous Supreme Court Slaps Down Familiar Sounding Marketing Allegations In Landmark Gun DecisionShrinking A Safe Harbor To Fit A Consumer Protection Class
In Hall v. Walgreens Boot Alliance, Inc., the Supreme Court of Washington considered a certified question from the Northern District of Illinois on an issue of Washington state law. No. 102829-6, 2025 Wash. LEXIS 145 (Wash. Mar. 20, 2025). The underlying case, a proposed consumer protection class action, involves the labeling of certain over-the-counter…