We are certain that profound revelations – scientific, economic, and political – will arise from the Covid-19 crisis. For now, we comment on bits of knowledge we have gained so far. We have learned, spending 24 hours each day with our dogs, that they bark 20 hours each day. We have learned that the concept
Search taxotere
Excellent Warnings Causation Decision out of the Taxotere MDL
By Rachel B. Weil on
Like most of you, and like our co-bloggers (from whom you will hear similar laments this week) we are in the midst of “social distancing.” We have locked down our home, begun an indefinite period of working remotely, ordered a case of boxed macaroni and cheese, and fielded emails cancelling an inordinate number of long-awaited…
Taxotere Court Finds that Distributor was Fraudulently Joined; Denies Remand
By Stephen McConnell on
Plaintiffs will go to great lengths to stay out of federal court, including naming local defendants against whom the plaintiffs have no real intention of pursuing the lawsuit with even a smidgen of seriousness. Sometimes that is called “improper joinder,” but we prefer the term “fraudulent joinder” because that more accurately captures what is afoot.…
Taxotere Court Excludes Expert Opinion on How the Medical Community Would Have Reacted to a Different Warning
By Stephen McConnell on
We write today about a partial exclusion of a plaintiff expert in the upcoming Taxotere bellwether trial. We have blogged about other aspects of the Taxotere litigation previously. (Here and here, for example.) The case is In re Taxotere (Docetaxel) Prods. Liability Litig., 2019 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 130339 (E.D. La. Aug. 5,…
The Two Most Significant New Ediscovery for Defendants Decisions
By Bexis on
In our recent ediscovery for defendants update, we highlighted two of the twenty-eight cases we included as the most important: In re Tasigna (Nilotinib) Products Liability Litigation, 2023 WL 6064308 (Mag. M.D. Fla. Sept. 18, 2023), and Davis v. Disability Rights New Jersey, 291 A.3d 812 (N.J. Super. App. Div. March 16, 2023). Today we’re explaining why.Continue Reading The Two Most Significant New Ediscovery for Defendants Decisions
FDA’s Brief To The Fifth Circuit in the AHM Case Is Worth A Read
By Eric Alexander on
Attempting to stay up on every filing in every medication abortion case could be a full-time job these days. We have one of those already, so we tend to stick to court rulings. The filings in the Fifth Circuit on the AHM appeal are something of an exception. In addition to party briefs, the…
Only in an MDL….
By Bexis on
Some things make sense only in the topsy-turvy, litigate-everything-to-death world of multidistrict litigation. One recent example is In re Taxotere (Docetaxel) Products Liability Litigation, 2023 WL 2982464 (E.D. La. March 8, 2023), where MDL-related considerations led a defendant to oppose a plaintiff’s motion for voluntary dismissal with prejudice.
Why? Think chess. In MDLs the other side treats plaintiffs like pawns, regularly sacrificing them in the hope of putting one or more defendants in zugzwang (a chess term for forcing an adverse move). That’s what happened in Taxotere. Continue Reading Only in an MDL….
Even The Most Lenient Of MDL Judges Has A Limit For Excusing Plaintiff Lawyer Neglect
By Eric Alexander on
Stop us if you have heard this before. One of the big problems with MDLs in the era of unchecked lawyer advertising, litigation funding, and the focus of MDL judges on mass settlement is that a high percentage of plaintiffs never have to do any heavy lifting between filing their cases and participating in some…
The Thrill of Victory – The Ten Best Prescription Drug/Medical Device Decisions of 2022
By Bexis on
So, another year has passed. 2022 is in the books and the republic still stands, even if Roe v. Wade (and, soon, Twitter) do not. The COVID-19 pandemic – if not COVID-19 itself, which has instead become endemic – is largely over, except for some probably PREP Act preempted shouting.
For the Blog, the end of the year means that it’s time for our annual celebration of the Drug & Device Law Blog’s top ten decisions of the year. Some of these cases establish important legal principles, such as preemption, Rule 702 expert exclusion (don’t say Daubert), or the learned intermediary rule. Others are important because they affect large numbers of cases gathered in the increasingly dysfunctional federal multi-district litigation system. Some do both. In either event, these decisions make the legal world at least somewhat less dangerous for our clients and (not incidentally) more favorable for us defense lawyers.Continue Reading The Thrill of Victory – The Ten Best Prescription Drug/Medical Device Decisions of 2022
MDL Counterpoint
By Bexis on
Not too long ago, we discussed the excessive indulgence of do-nothing plaintiffs in the Taxotere MDL – letting plaintiffs who took years just to serve their complaints slide. Continue Reading MDL Counterpoint