First, a minor correction. We lost by 6-3, not 6-2 (when you’re typing fast you’re all thumbs). We lost Kennedy, Thomas, and Breyer. We needed to win at least two of them.
The court relied on two facts established by the trial: (1) that a stronger warning would have made a factual difference (eliminating consideration
FDA Deference
Preemption And Guerilla Warfare
The Legal Intelligencer has a story today about the preemption loss in Knipe v. SmithKline Beecham. Since that adverse decision has made its way into the legal version of “mainstream media,” that means, under our self-imposed guideline of “first, do no harm” to the defense position in such matters, we’re now free to blog…
Tuckered Out
As most of our regular readers no doubt already know, not quite two weeks ago, we had to flip one of the cases in our Drug Preemption Scorecard. Specifically, the pro-preemption decision Tucker v. SmithKline Beecham Corp., 2007 WL 2726259 (S.D. Ind. Sept. 19, 2007) (“Tucker I”), became the anti-preemption decision,…
Users’ Guide To Defense Amicus Briefs – Wyeth v. Levine, Part II
A confession: There wasn’t supposed to be a Part II to this post.
When we posted our earlier users guide to the Levine defense amicus briefs, we thought we had included everything – we really did.
Shows what we know.
It seems our “good ol’ boys” approach to collecting the defense amicus briefs had a…
Users’ Guide To Defense Amicus Briefs – Wyeth v. Levine
It’s been said that the third time’s the charm. Maybe that means that we’ll get it right this time.
Anyway, as regular readers of this blog know, Wyeth filed its principal merits brief in Wyeth v. Levine early last week. As night follows day, that means that all defense amicus briefs are due a…
Delving into Colacicco
We promised you that we would be “mining the depths” of Third Circuit’s opinion in Colacicco v. Apotex Inc., 521 F.3d 253, 2008 WL 927848 (3d Cir. Apr. 8, 2008), affirming implied prescription drug preemption. That, of course, assumes that our doing so is a good thing. But we have to believe that most…
Preemption Affirmed in Colacicco
The Third Circuit has affirmed the finding of extensive preemption in the Colacicco/McNellis suicidality litigation. Here’s a copy of the opinion. Judge Sloviter wrote the opinion. There is a dissent, by Judge Ambro. This is the first federal court of appeals decision to address preemption following the FDA’s 2006 Preemption Preamble.
The…
More on Riegel
Now we’ve read it, and before we go off to celebrate (and maybe to look for new jobs as IP lawyers – that’s a joke, folks), we thought we’d tell our readers why that’s exactly what we’re doing.
The 7-1 Riegel decision definitively demolishes a lot of the arguments we’ve been seeing for years (if…
Collecting our thoughts on Wyeth v. Levine
Latest FDA/Solicitor General Preemption Amicus Filing – Kent
The Solicitor General, on behalf of the FDA, has recently filed amicus briefs in both the Riegel v. Medtronic and Warner-Lambert v. Kent (formerly Desiano) Supreme Court preemption cases. We’re doing a separate post on Riegel, but we did this one first because it’s more in the nature of “breaking news” – it…