Happy Halloween. We are very old school when it comes to this spooky holiday. Our pumpkins are orange, our candy bowl is full of Kit Kats, and our favorite horror movies are black and white Universal monster movies from the 1930’s and 40’s. To our ears, nothing screams Halloween quite like the great Una O’Connor
October 2018
Third Circuit Rejects Failure to Report Claims
Failure to warn claims premised on a failure to report incidents to a federal governing agency are preempted in the Third Circuit. Sikkelee v. Precision Airmotive Corporation, — F.3d –, 2018 WL 5289702 (3d. Cir. Oct. 25, 2018). And this would be a DDL Blog drop the mic moment if the ruling had come…
On Prevention of Federal Fraud on the FDA Claims That Avoid Buckman
Private plaintiffs love to scream “fraud on the FDA”! Agency fraud is their magic potion for dissolving any FDA action that they don’t like. Just assert that the FDA was bamboozled and invite some jury somewhere to ignore what the FDA actually did. Unfortunately for the other side, Buckman Co. v. Plaintiffs Legal Committee,…
Pennsylvania Preemption Win Now Final
A year and a half ago we celebrated a rare prescription drug preemption win in the Philadelphia County Court of Common Pleas. Then the decision was appealed, and we held our breath. Preemption is never an easy sell in state courts, and Pennsylvania appellate courts are not exactly defendant friendly in prescription medical product liability…
J.P.M.L. Denies Request for New Gadolinium MDL
J.P.M.L. Denies Request for New Gadolinium MDL
“Eventually, all things merge into one, and a river runs through it. The river was cut by the world’s great flood and runs over rocks from the basement of time. On some of the rocks are timeless raindrops. Under the rocks are the words, and some of the…
Judicial Estoppel: Failing to Disclose MDL Lawsuit as Asset in Bankruptcy Prevents Plaintiff From Pursuing Case
Happy birthday, Aubrey Drake Graham. Most people know Mr. Graham strictly by his middle name. The Canadian rapper Drake has carved out a hugely successful career for himself. He sells lots and lots of records – or whatever it is that they sell in the music business these days. Surprise: Drake’s music isn’t exactly our…
Uninjured Class Members Means No Class Certification
What happens when you have a class action where some putative class members suffered an injury while others did not? Can such a proposed class even be certified? The answer depends on whom you ask. The plaintiffs/class representatives will surely point out that whether any individual class member actually suffered a compensable injury is a…
Extracting a Toll from Litigation Tourists
Not long ago we published, as a guest post, a 50-state survey of state tolling statutes that governed whether, and under what circumstances, actions dismissed on a non-merits basis could be refiled notwithstanding the running of the applicable statute of limitations in the interim.
Bexis had never really thought much about these kinds of statutes…
This Post Comes with No Sugar Added
This post comes from the Cozen O’Connor side of the blog.
Today’s story is about a class action, one in which the defendant was sued for labeling its product “No Sugar Added” even though everyone involved, including the plaintiff, understood from the very start that no sugar had been added to the defendant’s product.…
Guest Post – What Does Your Dismissal Without Prejudice Mean? − A 50 State Survey of Savings Statutes
Today’s guest post was is a group effort of Betsy Chance, Diana Comes, and Mac Plosser, all at the Butler Snow firm. A little while ago they circulated (we don’t remember exactly how) an earlier version of a 50-state survey they had put together on state tolling statutes that preserve lawsuits that…