We’ve discussed personal jurisdiction a lot on the Blog lately, and not so lately, and for good reason. The Supreme Court’s reining in of both general and specific jurisdiction provides additional ways for defendants to win cases – particularly where the other side isn’t paying enough attention to the now more difficult legal environment. The
2018
Hoosier Daddy, Pt. 4: Plaintiff Who Refused IME Cannot Use Absence of IME to Attack Defense Expert
This will be the third consecutive week for us to discuss a favorable expert ruling out of the Cook Medical IVC filter litigation in the Southern District of Indiana. By this point, we really do expect some sort of remuneration from the Indiana Chamber of Commerce – maybe tickets for the surprisingly impressive Colts, or…
Discovery Rule Rules the Day on Statute of Limitations Motion to Dismiss
Geographical pride. A feeling of community. Belonging. Being one of the locals. We all experience it to some degree. Sometimes you take it with you. Like wearing your favorite Roll Tide t-shirt while listening to jazz in New Orleans. While Pennsylvanians may not take kindly to out-of-state sports jerseys, they welcome Maine lobster and Delaware…
Pro-Plaintiff Hijacking Attempt Against New York Statute of Limitations
We maintain a number of “scorecards” on legal issues where we judge the defense advantage is sufficiently great that including all cases, even if adverse, does not violate our injunction against doing the other side’s research for them. Three of the scorecards – PMA preemption, generic preemption, and innovator liability, pretty much update…
Trying To Reheat A Turkey
As we roll out of bed on the day after Thanksgiving, we are often confronted with contradictory thoughts. For instance, “why did I have that third plate at dinner?” might be followed by “How can I eat some leftovers for breakfast?” Leftovers are as much of an American tradition on this day as watching videos…
Hoosier Daddy, Pt. 3: S.D. Indiana Excludes Treating Physician Causation Opinions Not Formed During Course and Scope of Treatment
Last week we praised the S.D Indiana court’s Daubert decision in the Cook IVC filters litigation. Apparently the court is an expert on experts, because it came out with another sensible decision on experts, this time on the use of treating physicians to offer causation opinions. In re Cook Medical IVC Filters Mktg., Sales Practices…
Another Nationwide Class Action Bites the Dust Under BMS
Bexis saw Bohemian Rhapsody last week and, as a result, is suffering from multiple Queen earworms. One is from the title song itself – “Caught in a landslide, no escape from reality.” Come to think of it, that one may also be due to the recent election. Another one is that great bass riff –…
Sunset for Cy Pres, or Standing in Cyber-Privacy Litigation – Take Your Pick
We’ve always hated the concept of cy pres class action settlements. A cy pres distribution is an admission that, even without opposition, the plaintiffs cannot prove who was injured and by how much. Cy pres also takes money supposedly belonging to the injured class and give it to charities not injured by anyone, so the…
FDA Publishes Draft Updated Guidance on Medical Device Cybersecurity
We celebrated National Cybersecurity Awareness Month a few weeks ago by bringing you the FDA’s newly published Medical Device Cybersecurity Regional Incident Preparedness and Response Playbook, with a promise to cover the Agency’s promised update on its Guidance for Content of Premarket Submissions for Management of Cybersecurity in Medical Devices, which was first…
Guest Post – Revisiting the Third Circuit’s Struggles With Design-Defect Preemption
Today we have another guest post by long-time friend of the blog, Dick Dean, and his colleague at Tucker, Ellis, Mike Ruttinger. Regular readers will recall, that right after Sikkelee v. Precision Airmotive Corp., ___ F.3d ___, 2018 WL 5289702 (3d. Cir. Oct. 25, 2018), was decided, we blogged about the…