Truly unique cases are, well, unique. Most cases involve variations or combinations of cases we have seen before. Sometimes you get different results between two decisions on basically the same case with a single fact different. In February, we posted on an Eastern District of Pennsylvania decision on a motion to dismiss in a case

If we were to recap briefly our reactions to the Levine decision and ten years of decisions attempting to apply it, then we might say something like this. The Court’s creation of a clear evidence standard for conflict preemption in the context of warnings claims for branded drugs was both novel and misguided. The Court

The toughest thing about defending product liability cases is the occasional immersion in human misery.  Securities and antitrust cases pose intellectual challenges but they are, in the end, pretty much about money.  By contrast, the plaintiffs in our cases are claiming injuries to their bodies, not just their wallets.  Sometimes those alleged injuries are phony

Recently Rudy Giuliani was broiled for saying that the truth isn’t the truth.  Denying a tautology won’t typically earn one high marks for logic.  Add in the callback to Pontius Pilate’s “What is truth” question, and it sounds like bad epistemology in service of bad morality.  But we’re not here to talk politics.  Nor are

Last year’s list of the Ten Worst DDL cases was remarkable because all ten decisions came from appellate courts.  Yikes.  And it is not as if the bad appellate decisions were spread around.  Two came from our home circuit, the Third.  Two came from the reliably problematic Ninth Circuit.  But the ‘winner’ was the Eleventh

There are plenty of f-words in this post, but fear not, for they are all fully capable of traveling in polite company. Most are even family-friendly. The most tasty f-word here is the “F” in FDA: food. While we focus on drug and device cases in this blog, we frequently find that food cases furnish

We’ve come to expect top-flight work product from the Product Liability Advisory Council (PLAC), even when it isn’t Bexis pushing the pen or pecking at the keyboard (as he has done so many times on so many important issues). PLAC’s amicus brief in support of the petition for certiorari regarding the Third Circuit Fosamax case