Here is a question the First Circuit has now answered the wrong way — can a scientific paper published before the FDA approved a drug nonetheless qualify as “newly acquired information” that triggers a duty to change the warnings under the Changes Being Effected regulation? The Fifth Circuit said no last year in Hickey.
CBE Regulation
When Plaintiff’s Experts Ghost Their Own Depositions
Same Drug, Different Result: Welcome to the Taxotere Time Warp
If you ever needed proof that timing is everything, the Taxotere litigation has you covered.
Last month, a court denied summary judgment to the brand manufacturer, finding that it allegedly acquired “newly acquired information” post-dating Taxotere’s original FDA approval in 1996. This month, however, the very same court granted summary judgment to the …
True Confessions of a Doomed Failure to Warn Claim
There is a special kind of optimism—some might call it magical thinking—that animates the modern failure-to-warn claim against prescription drug manufacturers. It goes something like this: Yes, the FDA-approved label warned about the exact risk that happened to me, but the manufacturer still failed to warn.
Which is a pretty accurate summary of plaintiff’s argument…
D. Mass Finds Pre and Post Approval Failure to Warn Claims Preempted
Prescription drug warnings require FDA approval which dictates what the manufacturer can say in the product’s labeling. An exception to the FDA-approval rule is the Changes Being Effected (CBE) regulation which allows a manufacturer to unilaterally change a drug’s warnings “to reflect newly acquired information” and where the revision would “add or strengthen a contraindication…
Split Decision in MDL “Bellwether Discovery” Case
Failure-to-Warn Claim Implicating Class II Medical Device that Received De Novo Classification Held Expressly Preempted on Facts Presented
[This post is from the non-Reed Smith side of the blog.]
Today we report on Dickson v. Dexcom, Inc, 2024 WL 4291511 (W.D. La. 2024), an important medical-device preemption case that started with a doctrinal bang but ended on a factual whimper.
Committed to nationally uniform standards based on good science, we believe that…
Has Albrecht Been Undone?
We do not mean the German Renaissance painter and thinker Albrecht Dürer. His work, while a poor cousin to that of some famous contemporaries to the south, remains as is. We mean the Supreme Court’s decision in Merck Sharp & Dohme Corp. v. Albrecht, 587 U.S. 299 (2019), which has been touted for the…
What’s Past is Prologue
A little over two years ago, we wrote a post called What’s In a Name? discussing an attempt by two plaintiffs to hold Pfizer liable for fraud and misrepresentation based on an allegation that it was misleading to call the drug Chantix by its name if it was contaminated. That case, as we noted in…
. . . Try, Try Again; But Enough is Enough
Is what the court finally had to tell plaintiff in Roshkovan v. Bristol-Myers Squibb Co., 2023 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 166742 (C.D. Cal. Sep. 19, 2023) in dismissing his second amended complaint as both preempted and inadequately pleaded. We posted about the dismissals of the original and first amended complaints on the same grounds here…