We pointed out earlier that Bristol-Myers Squibb Co. v. Superior Court, No. 16-466 (“BMS”), was not the only personal jurisdiction matter on the Supreme Court’s docket this term. Argued the same day as BMS was BNSF Railway Co. v. Tyrell, a Federal Employees Liability Act (“FELA”) personal injury case raising
May 2017
North Carolina Rejects Stengel in Complete Preemption Win
Put a New Yorker and a Californian in a room together and the debate will begin almost immediately. Hollywood v. Broadway. Atlantic v. Pacific. Dodgers v. Yankees or Giants v. Forty-Niners. Shake Shack v. In-N-Out (or is Five Guys overtaking both?). And more generally speaking that east coast/west coast divide extends beyond those two urban…
Supreme Court Expands Forum-Shopping Crackdown
Lack of Proximate Causation Dooms another Failure to Warn Claim
This post is from the non-Reed Smith side of the blog.
The plaintiff thought she had a strong summary judgment opposition. She included the deposition testimony of her prescribing doctor, who suggested that Boston Scientific’s warnings for the pelvic mesh device were inadequate. And she included her own affidavit, in which she said that she…
Picking Up the Post-Preemption Pieces
Parties often file motions in limine on fairly case-specific issues, building on the history of discovery and motions practice in the case. Applying a ruling on in limines from one case to another can be a dicey proposition as potentially significant differences in the facts, law, claims and defenses asserted, and other rulings can…
N.D. Florida Permits (Some) Discovery of Expert Who Changed from Consulting to Testifying Expert
Discovery regarding expert witnesses can be tricky. In our neck of the woods, the great Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, state courts almost never permit depositions of experts. If you want to ask the expert questions – and you will – you must wait until trial. The flip side of that restriction is that expert reports in …
Similar Claims but Opposite Results
This post originates from the non-Reed Smith side of the blog.
A federal judge in Texas recently ruled that Texas law does not allow a claim for negligence per se based solely on alleged violations of the FDCA or FDA regulations. Monk v. Wyeth Pharmaceuticals, Inc., 2017 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 72477, *21-23 (W.D. Tex…
Speaking of the First Amendment. . . .
Now that Dr. Scott Gottlieb is safely installed as FDA Commissioner, we at DDLaw can end our moratorium on blogposts about First Amendment issues. There was no way we wanted to give his opponents any ammunition by saying nice things about Dr. Gottlieb before his confirmation.
Not so now.
Given what Dr. Gottlieb has said…
Is the Government Protecting Your Private Information?
We were not affected by the recent ransomware attack that disabled computers worldwide, including in multiple public hospitals in the UK. At least not yet. For those who have never had the pleasure or who otherwise do not follow cybersecurity news closely, “ransomware” refers to an attack on a computer system that encrypts the user’s…