A postal worker picks up a leaking bottle of drain cleaner stuck on a conveyor belt and suffers severe chemical burns. The product was sold through an online marketplace and was made by a manufacturer that sells only bulk cases to hardware distributors. This wayward bottle was shipped in the US Mail illegally by someone
Informed Consent? Not in Our Sandbox!
There is still a lot of 2026 left, and the Blog has already published two posts discussing (among other things) informed consent claims brought against manufacturers of prescription medical products. The first post reviewed Graw v. Eli Lilly & Co., 821 F. Supp.3d 981 (E.D. Mo. 2026), where the plaintiff unsuccessfully brought such a claim…
Downstream Is Too Far: N.D. Illinois Dismisses School Districts’ Opioid Claims Against Marketing Vendors
A recent order from the Northern District of Illinois shows just how far public entities will go in trying to spread blame for opioid use and abuse, and in Baltimore City Board of School Commissioners v. Publicis Health, LLC, the district court found that a group of school districts reached too far. No. 24…
Whodunit? Not the Tanning Lotion
Every good mystery needs a red herring. The suspicious houseguest. The gardener with the shaky alibi. The tanning lotion sitting quietly on the bathroom counter while the actual culprit — a chiropractor-prescribed anti-inflammatory cream applied minutes before the plaintiff’s collapse — walks right past the detectives without so much as a raised eyebrow. That is…
Product Representatives are Not Surgical Supervisors: No Duty to Grab the Scalpel
Medical device sales representatives are many things. They know their product lines inside and out. They can tell a surgeon exactly where to find a particular screw, rod, or connector in a tray containing dozens of components. They can help ensure the requested hardware is available when needed. What they cannot do is scrub in…
Clinical Trial Sponsor Not Liable For Sponsoring Clinical Trial
Yes, we know our title is rather circular. In fairness, most of the allegations we have seen in cases attempting to impose liability on the sponsor of a clinical trial are too. We have been following proposed clinical trial liability in its various proposed forms for quite some time, including winning a jury trial…
Flooding The Zone Does Not Work For Opioid Plaintiffs In Maine
No Bespoke Products Liability Claims in Texas
Bespoke makes us think of tailoring, which makes us think of London’s Savile Row, which makes us think of Annie’s You’re Never Fully Dressed Without a Smile (“who cares what they’re wearing on Main Street or Savile Row”). Which as it turns out is perfect for today’s case about a plaintiff who wanted the court…
Post-Gilead Heartburn in the California Ranitidine Litigation
This post is from the non-Reed Smith, non-Dechert , and non-Holland & Knight side of the blog. Everyone else is involved.
The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly is a classic Clint Eastwood spaghetti Western where even the Good may not be all good. In California state court, a demurrer sustained is a defense win, right? Although there are some bright spots, In re Ranitidine Cases is one of the ugliest defense wins we have seen in a while, providing leave to amend and a roadmap for further expansion of the Gilead duty-to-innovate.
Continue Reading Post-Gilead Heartburn in the California Ranitidine LitigationThe Non-Existent Tort of “Failure To Recall”
It seems like once every couple of weeks, we see a story about some plaintiff (such as this one) suing, or threatening to sue, a defendant product manufacturer over some product that, according to the plaintiff, “the company should have recalled sooner.”
That’s garbage.
There is no such claim. Rather failure-to-recall theories are…